Skip to main content
May 31, 2026•Production Engineering

After an ESP Failure in Low Bottom-Hole Pressure, High-Gas Wells: Run Another ESP or Take the Production Hit?

Why the knee-jerk move to a smaller pump often backfires in gassy, low-pressure wells — and the design questions to ask before accepting the first ESP recommendation.

J
James BritvarEngineer

The Dilemma

What do you do when an ESP fails with low bottom-hole flowing pressure, moderate to high gas, and when production is still higher than it would be on rod lift? Do you run another ESP or take a possible production hit?

The biggest concern with running another ESP is whether or not it will run long enough to be economic. This is where equipment selection and using best practices with installation, assembly, and operation are most crucial.

Why Smaller Isn't Always Better

The knee-jerk reaction is to run a smaller pump: more often than not, dictated by last production volumes. However, smaller stage geometries have limitations such as gas handling efficiency.

These small stages more closely resemble radial stages than true mixed-flow stages, where flow paths are more restrictive and have larger angle flow transfer from impeller to diffuser (~90°). Excellent for generating head, but not so much for handling gas or solids. What we observe is they tend to struggle with gas interference in low bottom-hole pressure and GLRs above 500 scf/stb.

The Physics: Gas Expands as Pressure Drops

Consider PV = nRT. In terms of gas volume, V = nRT/P, where volume and pressure are inversely proportional. As pressure decreases, the volume of gas increases.

Even at lower GLRs, if bottom-hole pressure is low, gas locking can still be a concern.

Our Recommendation

In these scenarios, we will typically recommend no less than 1,000 barrel per day pumps in a double or triple taper configuration, including an axial flow type pump with advanced gas handling solutions like a boosted gas separator.

In reality, at 500 stock tank barrels per day the downhole system is seeing anywhere from 650–800 reservoir barrels per day, which is well within recommended operating range. The tapered design will help manage gas to keep operation as stable as possible.

Before You Accept the First Design

For the next ESP you run in these conditions, review these questions before accepting the first design recommended:

  • ✅ Plot GOR, GLR, and water-cut through time. Is GOR above 500 scf/stb?
  • ✅ Is there evidence of gas interference with the prior installation? I.e., unstable motor/drive current, minimal intake pressure drawdown, high temperature events.
  • ✅ Which pump was previously installed? Was it oversized/undersized? How long did it run and how much did production change during that time?
  • ✅ What production volumes do you anticipate in 3 months, 6 months, and beyond?